댓글 쓰기 권한이 없습니다. 로그인 하시겠습니까?
한국과학사학회지, 제37권 제3호 (2015), 555-592
[연구논문] ‘2007년 과학’ 대 ‘2008년 정치’?: 광우병 논쟁과 과학 자문의 정치 문화 (‘Science in 2007’ vs. ‘Politics in 2008’?: The Controversy over Mad Cow Diseaseand Political Culture of Scientific Advice in Korea)
by 하대청(HA Dae-cheong)
첨부파일 '1' |
---|
초록 | The safety standard on beef imports, to which the Lee Myung-Bak administration agreed in a negotiation with the United States in 2008, caused large- scale protests of citizens who had concerns about the possible risk of mad cow disease. This newly-settled standard was criticized as ignoring the more strict standard suggested by an expert advisory committee in 2007. It was assumed that the “political” power in 2008, expecting that the US Congress would ratify the Korea-US Free Trade Agreement, must have subdued the “scientific” advices of experts in 2007. This paper, regarding this situation as a tricky but significant controversy about the relationship between scientific advice and policy-making, analyzes the detailed practices of an expert advisory committee and a consultation meeting with stakeholders called the Animal Disease Control Council. This will show that scientific advice was entangled with political and cultural considerations, and especially that economic globalization contributed to a specific configuration related to the scientific advice on mad cow disease. This paper finally argues that the political culture of scientific advice deserves more attention, as it not only helps explain the controversy over mad cow disease but also disclose diverse factors underlying constraining risk assessment and the negotiation and boundary-making with policy-making. |
---|---|
주요어 | controversy over mad cow disease, Candlelight vigils in 2008, political culture of scientific advice, scientific advice, Expert Advisory Committee, Animal Disease Control Council |
하대청, "‘2007년 과학’ 대 ‘2008년 정치’?: 광우병 논쟁과 과학 자문의 정치 문화", 『한국과학사학회지』 37권 3호 (2015), 555-592.
Category
- 제45권 (2023)
- 제44권 (2022)
- 제43권 (2021)
- 제42권 (2020)
- 제41권 (2019)
- 제40권 (2018)
- 제39권 (2017)
- 제38권 (2016)
- 제37권 (2015)
- 제36권 (2014)
- 제35권 (2013)
- 제34권 (2012)
- 제33권 (2011)
- 제32권 (2010)
- 제31권 (2009)
- 제30권 (2008)
- 제29권 (2007)
- 제28권 (2006)
- 제27권 (2005)
- 제26권 (2004)
- 제25권 (2003)
- 제24권 (2002)
- 제23권 (2001)
- 제22권 (2000)
- 제21권 (1999)
- 제20권 (1998)
- 제19권 (1997)
- 제18권 (1996)
- 제17권 (1995)
- 제16권 (1994)
- 제15권 (1993)
- 제14권 (1992)
- 제13권 (1991)
- 제12권 (1990)
- 제11권 (1989)
- 제10권 (1988)
- 제9권 (1987)
- 제8권 (1986)
- 제7권 (1985)
- 제6권 (1984)
- 제5권 (1983)
- 제4권 (1982)
- 제3권 (1981)
- 제2권 (1980)
- 제1권 (1979)
Designed by sketchbooks.co.kr / sketchbook5 board skin