Skip to content
한국과학사학회지, 제33권 제1호 (2011), 41-88

[연구논문] 1934년 한의학 부흥논쟁: 한의학 정체성의 '근대적' 재구성 (Modernizing Korean Medicine: The Debate on the Revival of Korean Medicine in Colonial Korea in the 1930s)

by 전혜리 (Jeon Haelee)
Atachment
첨부파일 '1'
Extra Form
초록 In 1934, there was a severe controversy between advocates of traditional medicine in Korea and a biomedicine-trained doctor. Through the debate, the advocates of Korean medicine attempted to “modernize” their field and to secure an independent status that would guarantee the institutionalization of Korean medicine. Pursuing their independent standing, however, required the advocates to find a rationale that Korean medicine should be separated from Western medicine. They emphasized that there existed fundamental differences in both theory and practice between the two kinds of medicine. Cho Hunyoung (趙憲泳, 1900-1988), for example, successfully showed that Korean medicine was not only distinct from Western medicine but also complementary to it. In so doing, he made a parallel comparison between the two so that Korean medicine could be seen as a part of the “modern” medicine rather than of the “traditional” one. After the debate, practitioners of Korean medicine broadly accepted the newly established identity of Korean medicine as a counterpart of Western medicine. The advocates founded a journal, Oriental medicine (東洋醫藥), and promoted it as an independent space for the research of Korean Medicine. However, there was a limitation in the project for the self-reliance of Korean Medicine, since the “modernization” of Korean Medicine was achieved by making it as “the other” of Western medicine. Korean medicine couldn’t be entirely independent from the standards of Western medicine.
주요어 The debate on the revival of Korean Medicine, medical discourse, institutionalization of medicine,modernizingtraditional medicine, The otherness, Cho Hunyoung (趙憲泳)
전혜리 (Jeon Haelee), "[연구논문] 1934년 한의학 부흥논쟁: 한의학 정체성의 '근대적' 재구성 (Modernizing Korean Medicine: The Debate on the Revival of Korean Medicine in Colonial Korea in the 1930s)", 『한국과학사학회지』 33권 1호 (2011), 41-88

Category
List of Articles
분류 제목
제33권 제1호 [연구논문] 『漢城旬報』 및 『漢城周報』의 과학기술 기사로 본 고종시대 서구 문물 수용 노력 (The Choseon Government’s Efforts to Introduce Western Science and Technology under King Gojong: Based on Excerpts from the Hansung Sunbo and the Hansung Jubo file
김연희 (Kim Yeon Hee)
2011 1-38
제33권 제1호 [연구논문] 1934년 한의학 부흥논쟁: 한의학 정체성의 '근대적' 재구성 (Modernizing Korean Medicine: The Debate on the Revival of Korean Medicine in Colonial Korea in the 1930s) file
전혜리 (Jeon Haelee)
2011 41-88
제33권 제1호 [연구논문] 조선 후기 대규모 간척지 조성 과정과 기술적 특징 (Technological Process of Large-scale TidalReclamation in the Late Chosŏn Dynasty) file
양선아 (Yang Son-a)
2011 91-132
제33권 제1호 [기획논문] 대학 교양교육에서 STS 강좌의 현황과 과제 file
박진희, 조정미
2011 135-159
제33권 제1호 [비평논문] 과학기술과 예술의 만남 file
임경순
2011 161-191
제33권 제1호 [비평논문] 탈국경적·학제간·협동생태적 연구로서의 동물행동학의 발달: 20세기 초중반 본능이론을 중심으로 file
정혜경
2011 193-227
제33권 제1호 [서평] Lorraine Daston and Peter Galison, Objectivity file
이기복
2011 229-354
제33권 제1호 [서평] Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway, Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming file
김준수
2011 241-248
제33권 제2호 [Research] Matteo Ricci’s World Maps in Late Joseon Dynasty file
LIM Jongtae
2011 277-296
제33권 제2호 [KJHS Forum] Rethinking the Technology Gap file
PARK Buhm Soon
2011 297-300
제33권 제2호 [KJHS Forum] Technology Gap, Research Institute, and Contract Research System: The Role of Government-funded Research Institute in Korea file
MOON Manyong
2011 301-316
제33권 제2호 [KJHS Forum] The Historical Development of Technological Capabilities in Korean Steel Industry: The Case of POSCO file
SONG Sungsoo
2011 317-334
제33권 제2호 [KJHS Forum] The "Kreaniztion" of Nuclear Power Technology: The case of a Joint Design file
KIM Byung-Koo
2011 335-347
제33권 제2호 [Retrospect and Prospect] Memoirs of the Early Days of the Korean History of Science Society file
JEON Sang-Woon
2011 349-358
제33권 제2호 [Retrospect and Prospect] My Kind of 'Bucket List' file
PARK Seong-Rae
2011 359-380
제33권 제2호 [Book Review] Andrew Pickering, The Cybernetic Brain: Sketches of Another Future file
KIM Hyomin
2011 381-386
제33권 제3호 [연구논문]'가장 과학적인 문자'와 근대 기술의 충돌: 초기 기계식 한글타자기 개발 과정의 문제들, 1914-1968 (The Conflict between “the Most Scientific Character System” and Modern Technology: Issues in the Early History of Korean Mechanical Typewriters, 1914-1968) file
김태호 (Kim Tae-Ho)
2011 395-436
제33권 제3호 [기획논문] 행주산성 전투에 사용된 변이중 화차의 복원 (A Study on the Fire Vehicle of Byun Eejoong) file
김평원 (Kim Pyoung-Won)
2011 477-508
제33권 제3호 [기획논문] 조선의 8척 규표 복원 연구 (A Study on the Restoration of 8 Chi Gnomon of Joseon Dynasty) file
이용삼, 양홍진, 김상혁 (LEE Yong Sam, YANG Hong-Jin, KIM Sang Hyuk)
2011 509-531
제33권 제3호 [기획논문] 남병철 『의기집설』의 험시의(驗時儀) 연구 (Nam Byeongcheol‘s Time-checking Instrument in Nineteenth-century Korea) file
남경욱 (Nam Kyoung Uk)
2011 533-571
제33권 제3호 [서평] 히피, 물리학의 길을 묻다 How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival file
천현득
2011 573-580
Board Pagination ‹ Prev 1 Next ›
/ 1

Designed by sketchbooks.co.kr / sketchbook5 board skin

나눔글꼴 설치 안내


이 PC에는 나눔글꼴이 설치되어 있지 않습니다.

이 사이트를 나눔글꼴로 보기 위해서는
나눔글꼴을 설치해야 합니다.

설치 취소

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Sketchbook5, 스케치북5

Phone +82-2-3703-9341 / Email khssociety@gmail.com
© The Korean History of Science Society 2014

Powered by Xpress Engine / Designed by Sketchbook

sketchbook5, 스케치북5

sketchbook5, 스케치북5

나눔글꼴 설치 안내


이 PC에는 나눔글꼴이 설치되어 있지 않습니다.

이 사이트를 나눔글꼴로 보기 위해서는
나눔글꼴을 설치해야 합니다.

설치 취소